| Year | Winner | MVP |
| 2017 | West | Maya Moore |
| 2015 | West | Maya Moore |
| 2014 | East | Shoni Schimmel |
| 2013 | West | Candace Parker |
| 2011 | East | Swin Cash |
| 2009 | West | Swin Cash |
| 2007 | East | Cheryl Ford |
| 2006 | East | Katie Douglas |
| 2005 | West | Sheryl Swoopes |
| 2003 | West | Nikki Teasley |
| 2002 | West | Lisa Leslie |
| 2001 | West | Lisa Leslie |
| 2000 | West | Tina Thompson |
| 1999 | West | Lisa Leslie |