2007
First Team
Tamika Catchings, Forward, Indiana Fever
Lisa Jackson, Center, Seattle Storm
Katie Douglas, Guard, Connecticut Sun
Alana Beard, Forward, Washington Mystics
Deanna Nolan, Guard, Detroit Shock

Second Team
Tully Bevilaqua, Guard, Indiana Fever
Rebekkah Brunson, Forward, Sacramento Monarchs
Margo Dydek, Center, Connecticut Sun
Loree Moore, Guard, New York Liberty
Chelsea Newton, Guard, Sacramento Monarchs

2006
First Team
Tamika Catchings, Forward, Indiana Fever
Lisa Leslie, Center, Los Angeles Sparks
Sheryl Swoopes, Forward, Houston Comets
Tully Bevilaqua, Guard, Indiana Fever
Katie Douglas, Guard, Connecticut Sun

Second Team
Alana Beard, Guard, Washington Mystics
Margo Dydek, Center, Connecticut Sun
Deanna Nolan, Guard, Detroit Shock
Cheryl Ford, Forward, Detroit Shock
Yolanda Griffith, Forward, Sacramento Monarchs

2005
First Team
Tamika Catchings, Forward, Indiana Fever
Sheryl Swoopes, Forward, Houston Comets
Yolanda Griffith, Center, Sacramento Monarchs
Tully Bevilaqua, Guard, Indiana Fever
Katie Douglas, Guard, Connecticut Sun

Second Team
Lauren Jackson, Forward, Seattle Storm
Taj McWilliams-Franklin, Forward, Connecticut Sun
Lisa Leslie, Center, Los Angeles Sparks
Alana Beard, Guard, Washington Mystics
Deanna Nolan, Guard, Detroit Shock